What happened with Wellcare Value Script

Wellcare’s Value Script plan is the most popular stand-alone drug plan in Medicare, with close to 6 million members nationwide. For many people, it carried a $0 monthly premium in 2025.

For 2026, that changed in 26 states and Washington, D.C. Members who had been paying nothing suddenly had a small monthly premium — in some cases only a few dollars.

~140,000
Wellcare Value Script members were dropped in April 2026, some owing as little as about $8 for three months combined.
Source: NPR / KFF Health News

Here’s where things went wrong, according to the reporting:

  • The premium change was easy to miss. Wellcare says every member received the required Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) in September, and that it also reached out by phone, text, mail and email. But the new premium appeared on just a couple of pages inside a 21-page booklet.
  • Automatic Social Security deductions had quietly stopped. When a plan’s premium drops to $0, the Social Security deduction ends. Many members assumed it would restart on its own when the premium came back. It doesn’t — you have to set it up again.
  • Prescriptions kept getting filled during the grace period, so nothing seemed wrong. Medicare allows a two-month grace period for unpaid premiums; Wellcare extended it to three.
  • Then coverage ended. NPR and KFF Health News reported that roughly 140,000 Value Script members were dropped in April. Some owed as little as about $8 for the three months combined.

Why losing coverage is such a big deal

Once a plan drops you for nonpayment, you generally cannot rejoin or switch to another drug plan until Annual Enrollment, with coverage starting January 1 of the next year. Limited exceptions exist (for example, people who qualify for Extra Help), but most people simply had to wait.

That means months of paying full retail price for medications. And going 63 days or more without creditable drug coverage can trigger a Part D late enrollment penalty that is added to your premium for as long as you have Medicare.

People in the story were left paying out of pocket for blood thinners, blood pressure medications and other daily prescriptions — over a bill most of them would have gladly paid if they had known about it.

This isn’t just a Wellcare issue

Wellcare was the focus of this story, but any carrier’s premium can change from one year to the next, including plans that have been $0 for years. KFF Health News’ own analysis warned that more people in zero-premium plans from Wellcare and other insurers could face the same situation in the future if premiums rise and they don’t notice.

Your checklist: how to protect your coverage

  1. Open your Annual Notice of Change. It usually arrives in late September. Look for the line showing your monthly premium for next year, and compare it to this year.
  2. Don’t assume “$0” carries over. Confirm your 2027 premium, even if you’ve never paid one before.
  3. Set up a way to pay before January. Your options typically include an automatic deduction from your Social Security or Railroad Retirement benefit, automatic bank or card payments, or paying through your plan’s member portal. If your premium was $0 last year, you will likely need to set this up again.
  4. Don’t ignore mail, texts or calls from your plan — but verify them. Scams targeting seniors are everywhere, so it’s smart to be cautious. Instead of ignoring a message, call the member services number printed on your plan ID card (or call us) to confirm whether it’s real.
  5. Watch for a bill or a past-due notice in January and February. If you see one, act right away while you’re still in the grace period.
  6. Ask about Extra Help. If your income is limited, you may qualify for Medicare’s Extra Help program, which can lower your premium and drug costs.

If you lost your coverage this year

You can enroll in a new drug plan during Annual Enrollment, which ends December 7, 2026, for coverage that begins January 1, 2027. Please don’t wait — reach out to us and we’ll help you find a plan that covers your medications and set up premium payments so this doesn’t happen again.

Sources

Susan Jaffe, KFF Health News, “These Medicare beneficiaries thought their drug plan was free. Then they lost it,” published by NPR, July 6, 2026. Read the full article on NPR.

Additional 2027 premium information from Wellcare.com.